Greenwashing on Trial: a fictional brand convicted, a very real lesson
Can a brand really call itself 'climate neutral'? Interesting discussions around the EmpCo directive and greenwashing claims.
On Wednesday 18 November, the Danish-French Chamber of Commerce put greenwashing on trial at Copenhagen Business School. In front of an audience of members, partners and students, a fictional fashion brand, Fjordlin A/S, stood accused of misleading environmental marketing. By the end of the evening, it had been found guilty and fined 100,000 euros.
The case was built around the EU’s new EmpCo Directive, the rules designed to empower consumers for the green transition and to put an end to vague or unsubstantiated green claims. Fjordlin faced three charges: calling its collection “climate neutral” on the basis of carbon offsetting alone, marketing it with generic terms such as “eco-responsible” and “planet-friendly” without evidence, and displaying a self-made “Green Promise” label with no independent certification behind it.
The evening was opened by our President, Thomas Canguilhem, and by Marie Charlotte Grivel on behalf of CBS, and the trial then played out like the real thing. Kim Meurs-Gerken, Vice-President of the Chamber, presided. Navina Jegarubanathan (LEAD) led the prosecution, Christian Alsøe (Loeven) the defence, and Gösta Schwarck took the stand as Fjordlin’s CEO. Three expert witnesses gave evidence: Matteo Simonetto (TÜV SÜD, joining online) on verification, Louise Kofoed-Dam (EcoTree) on carbon offsetting, and Fanny Guay (VELUX) as the counter-example of credible, well documented communication. The students of CBS French Culture formed the jury and delivered the verdict.
The timing could hardly have been sharper. That very morning, the Danish Consumer Ombudsman announced it had called a real Danish clothing brand to order for the same kind of vague “sustainable” claims, insisting that environmental claims must be documented, typically through a life cycle assessment. Fiction and reality met on the same day.
The takeaway was clear: good intentions are not enough. Under EmpCo, a green claim has to be precise, substantiated and verifiable, or it is simply greenwashing. The evening ended with a networking cocktail, and given its success, we will certainly run this type of format again.
Our warm thanks to our speakers, to our hosts at CBS, and to everyone who joined us in court. See photos of the event by clicking on the photo below.